Buy Forbidden Island if this is your first cooperative game or you want 30 minutes; Gamewright lists it at 2-4 players. Buy Forbidden Desert if you have played co-ops before and want more bite; it is 2-5 players at 45 minutes.
We earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It does not change which games we recommend or what we say about them. How this site is funded.
Both are Matt Leacock designs published by Gamewright, both start at two players, and Desert is usually described as the sequel. That framing is slightly misleading -- they are not a progression so much as two difficulty settings of the same idea, and buying the wrong one first is a real risk.
The shifting board changes everything
In Forbidden Island tiles flood in place. The map degrades but it stays where it is, so you can plan a route two or three turns ahead and mostly rely on it.
In Forbidden Desert the storm physically moves the tiles. The layout you planned around is gone by your next turn. That single change is what makes Desert genuinely harder and also what makes it run longer -- you cannot plan ahead, so you re-solve the board every round.
At two players this matters more than at four. With two you have fewer actions to spend recovering from a shift, so Desert's punishment lands harder on a pair than on a group.
03Which one first
Island, unless you have played modern cooperative games before. It is deliberately gentle, it teaches the vocabulary of the genre -- roles, a rising threat track, a shared action economy -- and it is the cheapest way to find out whether co-op even suits the two of you.
The honest counter-argument: if you already know you like co-ops, Island will be solved inside a handful of games and you will have spent money on a tutorial. In that case skip straight to Desert.
