Skip to content
Table for Duo

Which Forbidden game should you buy for two?

Three boxes, one family, and the one everybody recommends is not the one we would buy.

By Scooter M. - - How we pick

Two people working through a cooperative survival board game together at a table

Buy Forbidden Desert. Gamewright publishes it for 2-5 players at 45 minutes, ages 10+, it is the best-regarded game in the family, and its listing is reliably in stock. Forbidden Island is the usual recommendation and is the gentler, shorter game, and as of 2026-11-19 its listing reports plainly in stock. Forbidden Jungle is the cheapest box, and Gamewright's own page for it never states that it is cooperative or names a designer.

We earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It does not change which games we recommend or what we say about them. How this site is funded.

Four games carry the Forbidden name, they are all sold as cooperative survival games for small groups, and the question of which one a pair should buy gets asked constantly -- usually as a three-way between Island, Desert and Jungle. The standard answer you will find everywhere is "start with Forbidden Island, it is the cheapest and simplest".

That answer came with a problem for most of this autumn: Forbidden Island had no buyable offer at all from late September onward, and advice you cannot act on is not advice. A priced listing for it returned on 2026-11-14 and settled over the weeks after, and as of 2026-11-19 it reports plainly in stock. So all three boxes on this page are straightforwardly buyable today, which was not true when it was written, and the comparison below is now about the games rather than about what you can get hold of.

We have not played any of these. Specifications come from Gamewright's own product pages, cited at the bottom, and availability was checked through the retailer we link rather than assumed. Where Gamewright does not state something, this page says so instead of filling it in from the other games in the series.

The four games, and what is actually buyable

  • Forbidden Island -- 2-4 players, 30 minutes, ages 10+. Matt Leacock, Gamewright. 58 cards, 24 island tiles, a water meter. The traditional entry point, and we cannot find a live listing for it.
  • Forbidden Desert -- 2-5 players, 45 minutes, ages 10+. Matt Leacock, Gamewright. 49 cards, 48 sand markers, 24 tiles, a storm meter. In stock, and the pick.
  • Forbidden Jungle -- 2-5 players, 45 minutes, ages 10+. Gamewright, subtitled Survive the Wild; the publisher names no designer. 42 cards, 24 web tokens, 24 tiles, 20 eggs, 15 hatchlings, 12 alien creatures, 6 pawns, 6 meter clips, a threat meter and its stand. In stock, and the cheapest of the three.
  • Forbidden Sky -- the fourth game. The only listing we found was a single copy at a price several times the others, which is out-of-print pricing rather than a shelf price. Named here for completeness; not recommended.
  • All of them are Plays at two on this site's labeling. None is built for exactly two, and none has a publisher-stated solo mode.

How we judged this

Three questions, and the third is the one that reorders the usual answer.

First, what does the game do at two players? These are cooperative games, so the player count does not create competition the way it does in a competitive game -- it changes how many actions you get per round against a threat that escalates on its own schedule. Fewer players means fewer actions between bad things happening, which generally makes a co-op harder rather than easier at two. That is worth knowing before you buy.

Second, how much fiddling is there? Co-op survival games live or die on whether the upkeep between turns is interesting or just work. Component counts are a reasonable proxy and the three differ a lot.

Third -- and this is the one most write-ups skip -- can you buy it? We check availability through the retailer we link before featuring anything, and a recommendation we cannot send you to buy does not go in a pick list. On this family that check does most of the work.

Forbidden Island: the usual answer, and why it is not ours

On design, the consensus is right. Gamewright publishes it for 2-4 players at 30 minutes, rated 10+, designed by Matt Leacock. It is 58 cards, 24 island tiles and a water meter, and it is the shortest and simplest of the family -- the cheapest way to find out whether cooperative games suit the two of you before committing to anything heavier.

The problem, for eight weeks, was that there was no live listing for it at all. This site carried no buy row for Forbidden Island from late September until 2026-11-14, when the same listing started returning a priced offer again and the buy row came back. So you can buy it today. What you should know is that as of 2026-11-19 the offer reports plainly in stock, the same as Desert. This claim has now been narrowed three times as the listing recovered -- no offer at all, then a future ship date, then thin stock, now simply in stock -- and we would rather correct it at every step than leave a stronger version standing than the evidence supports.

That has a practical consequence worth stating plainly, because it is the reason this page exists. Search demand for this game is real -- it is one of the more-searched things we cover -- and the advice everyone gives about it is currently unactionable. If you find a copy at a sane price from a seller you trust, it is a good game and a good first co-op. We just cannot be the ones to send you there.

For the eight weeks it had no offer at all, Forbidden Island was discussed here without a buy button: leaving it out of the page entirely would have been the dishonest choice, and giving it a buy button would have been the useless one. Now that the offer is back it is a pick below, with the ship-date caveat attached, which is the version of this page we would rather be publishing.

Forbidden Desert: the one to buy, and what the storm does at two

Gamewright publishes Forbidden Desert for 2-5 players at 45 minutes, rated 10+, also by Matt Leacock. It is 49 cards, 48 sand markers, 24 tiles and a storm meter, and it is both the best-regarded game in the family and the one whose listing is reliably in stock.

The mechanical difference from Island is the storm, and it is the reason the game is better. The storm physically moves tiles, so the board you planned around is not the board you act on -- a route you were two moves from completing can simply not exist by the time your turn comes back. That turns the game from a puzzle you solve into a situation you keep re-reading.

At two players that is genuinely harder, and we would rather say so than sell it as a feature. With fewer players you have fewer actions between storm cards, so there is less slack to recover with when a plan collapses. Pairs who want a co-op they will mostly win should know that this is the family's step up in difficulty, not its gentle option. The gentle option is Forbidden Island, which is buyable again as of 2026-11-14 after eight weeks without a listing -- so if what you want is a co-op you will mostly win, that is now a real choice rather than a dead end.

The honest downsides beyond that: 45 minutes is a real sitting rather than a filler, and the sand-marker upkeep is the fiddliest thing about it after the storm itself.

Forbidden Jungle: cheapest buyable, and two things the publisher will not confirm

Gamewright publishes Forbidden Jungle for 2-5 players at 45 minutes, rated 10+, subtitled Survive the Wild. You move pawns across a tile map trying to put a transportation portal back in service while a threat meter climbs. It is the cheapest of the three boxes you can actually buy.

Two gaps in the sourcing are worth more than the price difference, and we are flagging them rather than papering over them with what is true of the other two games.

It does not name a designer. Island and Desert are both Matt Leacock, and it would be the easiest thing in the world to assume Jungle is as well. Gamewright's page for it credits nobody, so we do not either.

More importantly, the page never actually says the game is cooperative. It lists cooperation among the things the game reinforces and it describes a shared objective -- getting the portal working so everyone can escape -- but it does not state cooperative play outright, and the product is not filed under the publisher's own cooperative games category. The retail listing describes it as a work-together team challenge. That is probably enough to infer a co-op, and we would still rather you knew the publisher has not said it in as many words before you buy it expecting another Forbidden Desert.

The other honest mark against it: the component list is by far the longest of the three. Eggs, hatchlings, alien creatures, web tokens, pawns, meter clips and a threat meter on a stand is a lot of table furniture for a 45-minute game, and fiddliness is the usual complaint about the later entries in series like this one.

Forbidden Sky, and why it is only a footnote

People do search for it against the others, so it would be strange to leave it out. Forbidden Sky is the fourth game in the series.

The only listing we could find was a single copy priced several times what the other three cost. That is the shape of an out-of-print game being resold, not a shelf price, and it is not something we are going to put a buy button on. If it comes back into normal distribution it belongs in this comparison properly; today it does not.

We are deliberately not describing how it plays or printing its player count, time or age, because we have not sourced them from the publisher and the point of this page is that we check before we tell you things.

If the family is not right for the two of you

Two alternatives, both covered here, and both built closer to a pair than anything with Forbidden on the box.

Sky Team is the one we would reach for first. Le Scorpion Masque publishes it for exactly 2 players at 15 minutes, rated 12+ -- one of you is pilot, one is co-pilot, and you land an aircraft by placing dice on a shared cockpit board without discussing which dice you are holding. It is the only cooperative game we cover that was designed for exactly two people, and the no-talking restriction produces a tension none of the Forbidden games reach. Worth knowing: its listing was unbuyable for much of the autumn and came back with a live offer this week, so check it is still there when you click.

Codenames: Duet is the other, and the easier sell. Czech Games Edition lists it at 2 or more players at 15 minutes, rated 11+, and it is the cooperative Codenames -- you give each other one-word clues and win or lose together. It teaches faster than any Forbidden game and it is the better pick if what you want is something to play repeatedly rather than a scenario to beat.

Who each pick is for

  • Forbidden Desert -- best for the pair who want the family's strongest game and do not mind losing. 2-5 players, 45 minutes, 10+, Matt Leacock, and in stock. The storm moving tiles under you is the whole appeal. Honest downsides: it is the harder game at two because you have fewer actions between storm cards, it is a 45-minute sitting, and the sand markers are fiddly.
  • Forbidden Jungle -- best for the pair who want the cheapest Forbidden box they can actually buy, or who already own Desert and want more of the same shape. 2-5 players, 45 minutes, 10+, in stock. Honest downsides: the publisher names no designer and does not state outright that it is cooperative, and it has the longest component list of the three by a distance.
  • Sky Team -- best for the pair who want a cooperative game actually built for two. Exactly 2 players, 15 minutes, 12+, and the silence is the mechanic. Honest downsides: its listing has been unreliable this autumn, and the no-talking rule is exactly the thing some pairs find frustrating rather than thrilling.
  • Codenames: Duet -- best for the pair who want a co-op they will play twenty times rather than a scenario they will beat once. Listed 2+, 15 minutes, 11+. Honest downsides: it is word-based, so it is a poor fit if either of you finds word games stressful, and it is listed 2+ rather than built for exactly two.
  • Forbidden Island -- buyable again since 2026-11-14, after eight weeks with no listing at all, and now a pick here. It is the gentler, shorter, cheaper way into the family. The listing took a few weeks to settle after it came back -- a future ship date at first, then limited stock -- but as of 2026-11-19 it simply reports in stock, at the lowest price we have recorded on it.

What we would buy

Picks drawn from the games covered on this site, chosen against the criteria above.

We earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It does not change which games we recommend or what we say about them. How this site is funded.

Forbidden Desert

Forbidden Desert

Plays at two2-5 players · 45 minutes · ages 10+

The sequel that fixes what people find flat about Forbidden Island, at the cost of fifteen more minutes.

A supports-more cooperative game that plays at two. The board physically shifts as the storm moves tiles, so the map you planned around is gone by your next turn.

Players
2-5
Playing time
45 minutes
Age
10+
Designer
Matt Leacock
Publisher
Gamewright

Who should skip it

Skip it if you want a short game. The shifting board means you cannot plan more than a turn ahead, and that stretches the running time.

Specs from Forbidden Desert - Gamewright (publisher).

Forbidden Island

Forbidden Island

Plays at two2-4 players · 30 minutes · ages 10+

The cheapest way to find out whether co-op games work for the two of you.

A supports-more cooperative game that plays at two. You collect four treasures from a sinking island of 24 tiles and escape before the water level rises past the exit.

Players
2-4
Playing time
30 minutes
Age
10+
Designer
Matt Leacock
Publisher
Gamewright

Who should skip it

Skip it if you have already played a modern co-op. It is deliberately gentle and you will solve it inside a handful of games.

$17.84 - View on Amazon

$20.99 15% off

#ad How we are funded - price as of November 21, 2026

Read the full review

Specs from Forbidden Island - Gamewright (publisher).

Forbidden Jungle

Forbidden Jungle

Plays at two2-5 players · 45 minutes · ages 10+

The cheapest Forbidden box you can actually buy right now, and the only one of the three whose publisher page never quite says it is cooperative.

A survival adventure for 2-5 players in the Forbidden series, subtitled Survive the Wild. You move pawns across a tile map trying to put a transportation portal back in service while a threat meter climbs. Contents: 42 cards, 24 web tokens, 24 tiles, 20 eggs, 15 hatchlings, 12 alien creatures, 6 pawns, 6 meter clips, a threat meter and its stand. Gamewright lists 2-5 players, 45 minutes and ages 10+, and names no designer.

Players
2-5
Playing time
45 minutes
Age
10+
Publisher
Gamewright

Who should skip it

Skip it if you want the family's best-regarded design. Forbidden Desert is the stronger game and its listing is reliably in stock, and Jungle carries far more fiddly components -- eggs, hatchlings, web tokens and a threat meter.

$17.84 - View on Amazon

$20.99 15% off

#ad How we are funded - price as of November 21, 2026

Specs from Forbidden Jungle - Gamewright (publisher: 2-5 players, ages 10+, 45 min, full contents, the portal objective; names no designer and does not state cooperative play outright).

Sky Team

Sky Team

Built for two2 players · 15 minutes · ages 12+

A fifteen-minute co-op you play in near silence, and the tension is extraordinary.

A two-player-only cooperative game. One of you is pilot, one is co-pilot, and you land an aircraft by placing dice on a shared cockpit board -- without discussing which dice you hold.

Players
2
Playing time
15 minutes
Age
12+
Designer
Luc Remond
Publisher
Le Scorpion Masque
Published
2023

Who should skip it

Skip it if you want to talk freely. The no-talking restriction is the whole game, and some pairs find that frustrating rather than thrilling.

$26.39 - View on Amazon

$32.99 20% off

#ad How we are funded - price as of November 21, 2026

Read the full review

Specs from Sky Team (board game) - Wikipedia infobox, Sky Team - Le Scorpion Masque (publisher).

Codenames: Duet

Codenames: Duet

Plays at two2+ players · 15 minutes · ages 11+

Built around two people and honest about it, though the publisher lists it as 2+ rather than two only.

A cooperative word-association game. You each see half of a shared key card and give one-word clues to guide the other to the right agents in a 5x5 grid, avoiding the assassin.

Players
2+
Playing time
15 minutes
Age
11+
Designer
Vlaada Chvatil and Scot Eaton
Publisher
Czech Games Edition

Who should skip it

Skip it if one of you thinks in wildly different associations from the other. That gap is funny once and exhausting by the fourth game.

$19.99 - View on Amazon

$24.99 20% off

#ad How we are funded - price as of November 21, 2026

Read the full review

Specs from Codenames: Duet - Czech Games Edition (publisher).

Common questions

+Which Forbidden game is best for 2 players?

Forbidden Desert, on design first and availability second. Gamewright publishes it for 2-5 players at 45 minutes, ages 10+, its storm mechanic is what makes the family interesting, and its listing is in stock. Forbidden Island is the usual recommendation and as of 2026-11-19 reports plainly in stock; Forbidden Jungle is cheaper but less well sourced.

+Forbidden Island vs Forbidden Desert vs Forbidden Jungle -- what is the difference?

Island is the shortest and simplest at 2-4 players and 30 minutes. Desert adds a storm that physically moves tiles, so the board changes under you, at 2-5 players and 45 minutes. Jungle is 2-5 players and 45 minutes with a threat meter and a portal objective, and carries the most components by a wide margin. All three are rated 10+ by Gamewright.

+Is Forbidden Jungle cooperative?

Almost certainly, but Gamewright's own product page does not say so outright -- it lists cooperation among the things the game reinforces and describes a shared escape objective, and the product is not filed under the publisher's cooperative games category. The retail listing calls it a work-together team challenge. We flag the gap rather than assert it, because the other two games in the family are explicitly cooperative and this one is not.

+Can you still buy Forbidden Island?

Yes, again. The listing stopped returning a buyable offer in late September and this site carried no buy row for it for eight weeks, including when this page was first written. A priced offer returned on 2026-11-14 and the buy row is back. As of 2026-11-19 the offer reports plainly in stock, at the lowest price we have recorded on it, so there is no caveat left attached to buying it. It remains a good game and a good first cooperative purchase.

+Are all the Forbidden games by Matt Leacock?

Forbidden Island and Forbidden Desert are both credited to Matt Leacock by Gamewright. Gamewright's page for Forbidden Jungle names no designer at all, so we do not credit one -- assuming it is also Leacock would be a guess.

+What about Forbidden Sky?

It is the fourth game in the series and we are not recommending it. The only listing we found was a single copy at several times the price of the other boxes, which is out-of-print resale pricing rather than a shelf price. We have not sourced its specifications from the publisher and so do not print them.

+Do cooperative games get easier or harder with only two players?

Generally harder. The threat in these games escalates on its own schedule regardless of how many of you there are, so fewer players means fewer actions between bad things happening and less slack to recover with. That is worth knowing before buying a co-op as a pair, and it is why Forbidden Desert is the family's step up rather than its gentle option.

Sources

We have not played these games. What we did instead is set out on how we pick.